Advertisement

Iowa legislature passes new ‘ag gag’ law

  • 163
    Shares

Pigs in a CAFO (concentrated animal feed operation). — photo via the United States Geological Survey, public domain

Two months after a federal judge struck down Iowa’s “ag gag” law as unconstitutional, the Iowa legislature passed a new, similar law on Tuesday.

The Agricultural Facility Trespass Act makes it a crime for a person to use “deception” to gain access to an agriculture production facility, or apply for a job at one, “with the intent to cause physical or economic harm or other injury to the agricultural production facility’s operations, agricultural animals, crop, owner, personnel, equipment, building, premises, business interest, or customer.”

When states first began implementing ag gag laws in 1990s, it was openly acknowledged that the laws were intended to prevent journalists and animal rights groups from engaging in undercover investigations at factory farms. In his Jan. 9, ruling Senior Judge James Gritzner of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa struck down the state’s previous ag gag law — the Agricultural Production Facility Fraud Act of 2012 — for just this reason.

“The law has the effect of criminalizing undercover investigations of certain agricultural facilities [such as industrial livestock farms] and those of interest to the general public, such as puppy mills,” Gritzner wrote.

But during floor debates in both chambers of the legislature on Tuesday, lawmakers supporting the bill claimed it was intended to prevent trespassing and enhance biosecurity at agricultural facilities (a category broad enough to include large-scale dog-breeding businesses), and not prevent the public from learning about abusive practices or unsafe conditions.

Sen. Ken Rozenboom, a Republican from Oskaloosa, said current law “simply does not protect against someone entering property under false pretenses.”

Those of us in animal agriculture lose sleep over the thought of certain foreign animal diseases that could devastate our farms and bring Iowa to its knees or, maybe, put Iowa flat on its back. The need for managing strict biosecurity practices is a critical component of this bill.

In the Iowa House, Republican Rep. Jarad Klein of Keota echoed those concerns, saying he was worried that people might lie on job applications in order to gain access to a pig farm to deliberately spread diseases like African Swine Fever.

“If we don’t make sure our biosecurity is really tight, then we could have a real, long-term economic impact in a very negative way to the entire state,” Klein said.

The state made similar arguments while defending its 2012 law, but Judge Gritzner explicitly rejected them, because existing laws already covered those concerns.

As to private property and trespass concerns, an already existing section of Chapter 717A of the Iowa Code provides that persons ‘shall not, without the consent of the owner’ do various acts, including entering the facility to disrupt or otherwise harm the operation.

Biosecurity is effectively and appropriately protected by the last section of Chapter 717A, which prohibits the willful possession, transportation, or transfer of ‘a pathogen with an intent to threaten the health of an animal or crop.’

“So we’re doing another bill pretty similar to the last one which is going to end up … costing taxpayers more money [to defend in court],” Democratic Rep. Sharon Stockman from Mason City said during the House floor debate.

On Wednesday afternoon, Gov. Kim Reynolds said in a press release she would since the bill on Mar. 14. The law will go into effect as soon as the governor signs it.


  • 163
    Shares

Comments:

  1. On one of my roadtrips with my father, we stopped at a very large cattle facility in Hereford, Texas. We parked the truck and started wandering around looking at the cattle (when i say huge, i mean this was a field as far as the eye could see dotted with black cattle) Suddenly this huge tractor with a cab on top came racing over and a man leaned out the window and yelled “You aint from PETA are ya?”

  2. Industrial ag could not even wait for the appeal on the first ag gag bill. The state will now end up spending even more money defending this. I don’t believe that the impetus for this bill is a concern for biosecurity. I think they want to keep the public from finding out what goes on behind closed doors. They know that many people would not support their products if they understood more about how they are produced.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep it free.

Voluntary contributions from readers like you help keep Little Village free for everyone.

Please consider a one-time or monthly sustaining contribution, in any amount.

Advertisement

A collaboration between The Englert Theatre and FilmScene

STRENGTHEN
GROW•EVOLVE

Help us build the greatest small city for the arts in America—right here in Iowa City. Learn more »

Donate Today

Strengthen • Grow • Evolve is a collaborative campaign led by two Iowa City-based arts nonprofits, The Englert Theatre and FilmScene that seeks a major reinvestment to strengthen the arts through modern and historic venues, innovative programming, and new models of collaboration.

Little Village's
BEST OF THE CRANDIC

The results are in! Find out which of your favorite CR and IC haunts took home a prize.